# Best real estate agents in Indianapolis for 2026
Plain-text alternate of https://realestateagentaiindex.com/answers/best-real-estate-agents-in-indianapolis

Answer: the current Real Estate Agent AI Index AI Visibility leaders in Indianapolis include Indy Home Pros Team, Mark Dietel Realty, Carrie Holle Group; every listed candidate first cleared public production, review, identity, and source-quality gates.

## Team shortlist (AI Visibility order, the published public ranking order)
1. Indy Home Pros Team | REMAX Advanced Realty | AI Visibility 47.8 (5 of 32 checks) | production: 520 sales · $149.1M | reviews: 243 (Google) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/indy-home-pros-team
2. Mark Dietel Realty | Mark Dietel Realty | AI Visibility 47.6 (5 of 32 checks) | production: 250 sales · $74.6M | reviews: 439 (Google) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/mark-dietel-realty
3. Carrie Holle Group | Compass | AI Visibility 42.5 (3 of 32 checks) | production: 79 sales · $51.0M | reviews: 109 (Google) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/carrie-holle-group
4. DeBoor Group | The Real Brokerage Inc. | AI Visibility 42.2 (3 of 32 checks) | production: 204 sales · $64.4M | reviews: 120 (Google) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/deboor-group
5. Lockstep Realty | eXp Realty | AI Visibility 28.4 (0 of 32 checks) | production: 292 sales · $110.4M | reviews: 330 (Google) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/lockstep-realty
6. The Gutting Group | Keller Williams | AI Visibility 27.5 (0 of 32 checks) | production: 61 sales · $28.8M | reviews: 163 (Google) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/the-gutting-group
7. Shelly Walters Realty Group | F.C. Tucker Company | AI Visibility 27.3 (0 of 32 checks) | production: 46 sales · $22.0M | reviews: 128 (Google) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/shelly-walters-realty-group
8. Annie Scott Realty Group | F.C. Tucker Company | AI Visibility 27.2 (0 of 32 checks) | production: 43 sales · $22.4M | reviews: 119 (Google) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/annie-scott-realty-group
9. Steve Clark Team | Compass | AI Visibility 27.1 (0 of 32 checks) | production: 126 sales · $57.6M | reviews: 112 (Google) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/steve-clark-team
10. Onward Realty Partners | Keller Williams | AI Visibility 27.1 (0 of 32 checks) | production: 55 sales · $23.8M | reviews: 111 (Google) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/onward-realty-partners

## Individual-agent shortlist (AI Visibility order)
1. Kyle Williams | Compass | AI Visibility 50.2 (7 of 32 checks) | production: 37 sales · $14.0M | reviews: 117 (FastExpert) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/kyle-williams
2. Stephanie Evelo | Keller Williams | AI Visibility 42.4 (3 of 32 checks) | production: 93 sales · $31.7M | reviews: 66 (FastExpert) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/stephanie-evelo
3. Tina Smith | CENTURY 21 Scheetz | AI Visibility 40.9 (3 of 32 checks) | production: 49 sales · $36.4M | reviews: 76 (Google) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/tina-smith
4. Peter Stewart | Keller Williams | AI Visibility 39.5 (1 of 32 checks) | production: 110 sales · $33.7M | reviews: 126 (FastExpert) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/peter-stewart
5. Summer Hudson | eXp Realty | AI Visibility 39.1 (1 of 32 checks) | production: 87 sales · $26.2M | reviews: 99 (Google) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/summer-hudson
6. Carly DeFazio | Compass | AI Visibility 37.5 (1 of 32 checks) | production: 33 sales · $14.3M | reviews: 39 (Google) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/carly-defazio
7. Stacy Barry | CENTURY 21 Scheetz | AI Visibility 27.9 (0 of 32 checks) | production: 65 sales · $31.2M | reviews: 195 (Google) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/stacy-barry
8. Logan Sanford | The Real Brokerage Inc. | AI Visibility 27.4 (0 of 32 checks) | production: 30 sales · $9.6M | reviews: 141 (Google) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/logan-sanford
9. Molly Hadley | F.C. Tucker Company | AI Visibility 27.2 (0 of 32 checks) | production: 69 sales · $23.2M | reviews: 118 (FastExpert) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/molly-hadley
10. Deborah Argenta | Keller Williams | AI Visibility 26.7 (0 of 32 checks) | production: 21 sales · $7.0M | reviews: 80 (Google) | profile: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/directory/deborah-argenta

Consumer Authority, production, and reviews are supporting context; the public order among qualified candidates is the proprietary AI Visibility Score.
Evidence edition: June 23, 2026. AI capture run: web-grounded-panel-primary4-2026-08-08.
Ranking placement cannot be purchased; inclusion is earned from public evidence (no pay-to-play).
Market data JSON: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/data/markets/indianapolis.json
Full market page: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/markets/indianapolis
Methodology: https://realestateagentaiindex.com/methodology